4.20.2008

Television is our culture. Every day we view thousands of images both on TV and outside on billboards and yet our country was founded on mere words. Postman and Paglia both make strong cases against and for television, but it is Postman’s arguments against TV that have influenced my thinking the most.

One main point made by Postman is the danger of a TV system where disastrous images are constantly juxtaposed with an electric toothbrush or an ad for tampons. Random unconnected images “works against this linear tradition (reasoning) and breaks the habits of logic and thinking”(283). Postman is worried that images of 5,000 deaths with out time for grieving or comprehending the disaster results in individuals who are separate from their emotions. Every image on TV is given the same weight, after all he explains that capitalism is the machine in America. Nazi Germany controlled all of the images for it’s regime, and here in America the major media corporations (ads) produce most of the images in our society. Just as Nazi Germany did not have the people’s best interests at heart, neither do ad companies who create images to sell products to the masses.

Which brings us to another point of Postman’s, while our society is taught to analyze and criticize the written word, students are hardly educated about reading images. He argues for teaching literacy because “ the only defense against the seductions of imagery is a literate education”(293). Paglia argues for a rigorous word-based education that students can then fill out with TV culture. She also claims “there is nothing pleasant about learning to read or think”(293). I think this attitude is disastrous for today’s media saturated students. How can you attempt to teach children with out the use of the media they are so accustomed to? Personally, I believe children need to be taught to read and criticize the authors and their ideas. However, I also believe that media education should begin in early elementary school. Kids should be informed that they are a target for media companies and that their own school may host “channel 1” or receive school supplies from large companies hoping to cash in on these unsuspecting consumers. Simply teaching written literacy will not protect children from the seductive world of images.

I also agree with Postman’s argument about the danger of reproducing images so many times that they lose their power and their original meaning. Postman claims we as a society are “rapidly losing any sense of sacrality”(290) because of our transformation into a visual culture. Different representations of images reproduced thousands of times results in an image that has lost all of its original meaning. Instead of examining a President like Reagan for his policy papers, people were more interested in his names for his wife and the fact that he ate jelly beans, symbols that made him popular. New research has shown that a 30 second commercial can actually affect who they vote for in elections. Should a biased 30 second spot be able to convince someone who should run the country? I think this is the best example of the dangers that can come from the "seductions of imagery" that Postman warned us about.

If people are better informed about media techniques and taught to analyze them in the same way as they are taught to analyze the written word, consumers would be protected from the capitalist machine. Schools need to expand their curriculum to include information about interpreting our media world.

3 comments:

Angela said...

I think it's interesting you bring up the prospect of educating young children about the media. I agree that it is something that children should be aware of because for this generation, the media is able to force their influence down their throats from the moment they are able to watch TV or recognize magazine ads. These influences ultimately last a lifetime and prevent any possibility for personal opinion. However, maybe I'm just a conspirasist, but I don't see this reaching the education system's curriculum anytime soon. With the obvious corporate sponsors of Coca-Cola and Underarmour stationed within the hallways of many public schools, I would not be surprised to discover any partnerships amongst these corporate giants with even more corporate giants. With all of these multi-billion dollar corporations working within play with each other, essentially no corporation would be left to stand alone and not in sponsorship with a business that funds public schools. With so much government spending geared towards public schools wasted away by Bush's "No Child Left Behind" program, public schools need any form of funding they can manage, even if it means to whore themselves away with media advertisements and throwing away the prospect of personal opinion.

CC said...

You make a really good point of explaining the desensitizing effects of television on viewers. An image that is shown repeatedly becomes removed from its original context, and therefore only becomes a picture with no actual background, and loses its meaning. Although I agree with this, I wonder if this is not the case with print as well. A phrase becomes popular and then a catch phrase, and sayings come to mean something that can be completely unrelated to why it was originally created. This can go back to advertising on television though, such as how commercial phrases always stick in our minds even if we may not remember exactly what they mean or realize that it is a marketing strategy.

MikeH said...

I think that media education should definatly be taught to young children.